Time To Rethink Animal Welfare
Balvik C. / We Animals
News » Time To Rethink Animal Welfare

Time To Rethink Animal Welfare

November is World Vegan Month, when we celebrate the animal liberation movement, remind everyone that every animal is someone, and look toward a better world for animals. But what does a better world look like? Is it bigger cages? Straighter racetracks? Fewer gas chambers? 

Or is it recognising that animals’ lives are their own, and that they deserve to live free from humans dictating what we deem ‘enough’ space, comfort, or freedom to justify exploiting and killing them? 

On the surface, the battle for improved animal welfare looks like a win for animals. Everyone, including those who want to entirely dismantle the systems that imprison animals, understands that the abolition of animal use won’t happen overnight, and that, until then, reducing their suffering can only be a good thing.

Welfare, A Pitstop, Not The Goal 

The problem isn’t with giving animals better living conditions; it’s with making welfare our goal. When we make improved conditions within the paradigm of use our highest bar, that’s the bar we’ll meet, and it’s not enough. The goal must be animal liberation.  

Imagine for a moment you’re a chicken exploited in the egg system. Day after day, night after night, you’re stuffed into a cage with so many other hens, you can’t stretch a wing. When someone dies, their body slowly sinks to the bottom of the hen pile, their rotting corpse filling the tiny space with a putrid stench. One day, you’re moved to a “free range” system, where as many as 2,500 hens are crowded into each hectare of space, the delicate tip of your beak can still be cut off, and your male babies are still ground up alive. Better? Maybe. Good? Definitely not. 

Only by challenging the speciesist system that treats animals as commodities can we truly transform their lives.

The flawed system in which animal use is accepted and only their treatment is debated is bursting with such examples. As a mother pig, would a future ban on farrowing crates be enough if your babies were still taken from you and killed for their flesh? As a sheep used for wool, are you grateful for not having huge swathes of your skin sliced off as a baby, even though you’re still dragged, kicked and beaten in the shearing shed, and killed when you’re deemed “spent”? 

Striking at the Root of Speciesism 

When you put yourself in animals’ place, you might find yourself less inclined to argue for “responsibly sourced” skins, or that camels are ‘treated well’ while being treated as living taxis, forced to carry humans around for photo ops. That’s the challenge everyone who respects animals must rise to – recognising speciesism as the root cause of why we accept using animals in any way and fighting for abolition. Welfare reforms may reduce some suffering; arguably, they can also increase it by perpetuating systems that should be dismantled. Imagine an argument for treating children better while exploiting them, or for legislation that would allow for women to be beaten only sometimes.

This World Vegan Month, I urge you to consider this: the problem isn’t how we use animals; it’s that we use animals. Only by challenging the speciesist system that treats animals as commodities can we truly transform their lives. 

Raise Your Standards: Urge RSPCA to End Support for Factory Farming  

In a system that normalises animal use, baby steps abound. Is it better? Sure. Is it enough? Not by a long shot.  

Sign the petition and urge the RSPCA to stop certifying factory farming. 

Take Action

Help Animals in 2026: Renew Your PETA Membership!

Donate Now
Call to Action Image